²ÝÁñÉçÇø

The rural agenda needs to be placed firmly at the heart of policy making after Government scrap HS2

MP for Buckingham Greg Smith said decisions affecting the countryside are made by people with 'no practical understanding' of rural communities and their livelihoods

Chris Brayford
clock • 3 min read
(From left to right) MP Greg Smith, Defra Secretary Therese Coffey, Countryside Alliance chief executive Tim Bonner, Jonathan Brunyee and Conservative Rural Forum chair Lizzie Hacking
Image:

(From left to right) MP Greg Smith, Defra Secretary Therese Coffey, Countryside Alliance chief executive Tim Bonner, Jonathan Brunyee and Conservative Rural Forum chair Lizzie Hacking

Conservative MP Greg Smith has criticised policy decisions which have had lasting impacts on farmers and rural communities after the Government scrapped HS2 this week.

Prime Minister Rishi Sunak told the Conservative Party Conference (CPC) on Wednesday (October 4) the high-speed rail infrastructure leg between Manchester and Birmingham would be scrapped with £36 billion, instead, reinvested into public transport and roads outside of London in the future.

Mr Smith, who represents Buckingham, was speaking at a Countryside Alliance fringe event at the Conservative Party Conference alongside Defra Secretary Therese Coffey, condemned decisions made by civil servants and Government funded organisations who had ‘no practical understanding of the countryside and farming communities' - particularly in reference to those who had been affected by HS2.

Having called on the Government to scrap HS2 altogether, he added: "Too many decisions affecting the countryside are made by people who do not understand farmers or how to run farming businesses.

"I do not mean politicians or ministers when I say this, but civil servants and ‘arms-length' organisations like HS2 which has ripped through rural communities and demolished farms.

"Too many decisions are made by people from London, Birmingham and Manchester who do not understand the countryside.

"They have no practical understanding of the countryside and farming.

"There are things the Government are on top of already but I do understand there are also things it needs to work on as well.

"The rural agenda needs to be placed back at the heart of policy making."

Former PM David Cameron was disappointed by the Government's decision at CPC - describing the new course of action as a ‘once-in-a-generation' opportunity which was now lost.

Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham has said the derailment of the scheme between Manchester and Birmingham had placed Northern citizens 'firmly as second-class citizens'.Ìý Ìý Ìý ÌýÌýÌý

West Midlands Mayor Andy Street called out the decision as as a ‘failure to level up the North'.

Transport Secretary Mark Harper confirmed farmers and communities affected by HS2 would not be granted any new compensation following Mr Sunak's decision.

HS2 said the project was a ‘catalyst for growth' in Britain - intended to connect people across the country by cutting journey times, create more space and boosting jobs outside London by 'respecting communities and ensuring value for money'.

More on Politics

Agriculture split over EU reset summit delay caused by Starmer's resignation

Agriculture split over EU reset summit delay caused by Starmer's resignation

Crop group says pause will enable parties to better prepare while meat industry warns further hold-ups will only fuel farmer frustration

Jane Thynne
clock 25 June 2026 • 2 min read
From the editor: Can we move on from a decade of political drift?

From the editor: Can we move on from a decade of political drift?

This week from the ²ÝÁñÉçÇø Guardian editor Katie Jones

Katie Jones
clock 25 June 2026 • 2 min read
10 years on: What has changed for farming a decade after Brexit?

10 years on: What has changed for farming a decade after Brexit?

On the tenth anniversary of the vote to leave the European Union, Cedric Porter takes a look at the changes in the industry since the referendum

Cedric Porter
clock 23 June 2026 • 7 min read