草榴社区

The UK's Premier Agricultural Machinery and Technology Show

20鈥�21 January 2027, NEC, Birmingham

Event Details

Letters: Labour policy on TB 'mad and dangerous'

This week's letters from 草榴社区 Guardian readers (October 27)

clock 鈥� 2 min read
Bovine TB is a huge worry to farmers
Image:

Bovine TB is a huge worry to farmers

More depressing news for farmers as if they have not got enough. Every cattle farmer in the country must be furious and extremely worried by your front page article 鈥楶laying politics' (FG, October 20), telling of the mad and dangerous Labour Party's intention to ban badger culling.

Every available tool is needed to keep bovine TB as low as possible until a cattle vaccine is available. Culling has proved a very effective part in reducing numbers and the proof is in the figures quoted in the article. For the first time in 15 years, fewer than 20,000 cattle were slaughtered last year and herd outbreaks were at the lowest since 2008.

Listen to the podcast '草榴社区 see no end to Bovine TB' now:听

This is an utterly devastating policy by Labour which ignores facts and the increased financial costs that will follow and will only appeal to a tiny minority of the urban population. Tenant farmers are being squeezed out by Defra's divisive environmental schemes which favour landlords and estates in 鈥楨nvironment schemes want tenant farmers gone' (FG, October 20).

Under these new schemes, landlords and estates can take out land from being productive agricultural land worked by tenants and back into ownership, thereby collecting the monies offered in the environmental schemes themselves. Why is it that Defra always designs such rotten schemes? Is it out of ignorance or deliberate? Reading John Thorley's Farming Matters article on the back of the same edition - 鈥楨nvironment is important, but so is feeding the nation', one begins to conclude that the green blobs' influence and rewilding are determined to rid the country of agricultural food production.

But they forget that without farmers managing our land, we would lose most of our beautiful landscapes too, particularly in the uplands and our National Parks, when it would soon become covered in scrub.

Suzanne Greenhill, Bishops Cleeve, Gloucestershire

  • If you would like to send us a letter for consideration, please note that our email address has now changed to [email protected]

More on Blogs

OPINION: After another disastrous week, where does Defra go from here?

OPINION: After another disastrous week, where does Defra go from here?

Thousands of farmers were locked out of SFI26 Window 2 sparking an outpouring of anger and upset. This is not the first time the schemes have caused trouble but with the challenges now facing farming, it needs to be the last

Jane Thynne
clock 24 September 2026 鈥� 3 min read
James Robinson on bTB: "APHA are forcing us into an endless cycle of testing and killing our cows"

James Robinson on bTB: "APHA are forcing us into an endless cycle of testing and killing our cows"

Cumbrian dairy farmer and 草榴社区 Guardian In Your Field writer, James Robinson, provides an update on the bovine TB situation on his farm and his growing frustration at not being able to identify the root cause

James Robinson
clock 18 September 2026 鈥� 9 min read
OPINION: Rhetoric is all very well, but it won't keep your farm afloat

OPINION: Rhetoric is all very well, but it won't keep your farm afloat

Political grandees were out in force this week to support the Campaign for the Countryside. While their words captured the headlines, farmers know its actual policy that counts

Jane Thynne
clock 17 September 2026 鈥� 3 min read